THE CONSTANT GARDENER (R) ***1/2
Directed by Fernando Meiralles. 129 minutes.
Starring Ralph Fiennes, Rachel Weisz, David Nighy, Pete Postlethwaite
and Danny Huston. Released by Focus Features.
Brazilian director Fernando Meiralles is shaping up to be
one of the most interesting filmmakers around. He has taken the reigns from
director Costa Gavras as the poet of the impoverished and has become, with only
two films, a most angry and daring filmmaker. His first film, City of God, might be the best debut I have seen
in the past five years. That film chronicled the drug wars in the ghettos of Brazil. With The Constant Gardener, which is based on
the novel by John Le Carre, Meiralles has made a film much like Gavras’
political thrillers of the late 1960s and early 1970s, such as Z or State
of Siege.
Like Gavras, Meiralles uses the thriller genre to rail against corrupt
political regimes and, in this film, multimillion dollar corporations that exploit
environments in poor countries where life is already cheap.
In the film, Ralph Fiennes plays a British diplomat named
Quayle who instantly falls in love with a young activist named Tessa, who is
played by Rachel Weisz. They fall in love and she asks him to take her to Africa, where she becomes involved in trying to stop a
gigantic producer of potentially dangerous medicines from testing their product
on AIDS victims and poor people in the small African villages. At the beginning
of the film, Quayle finds out that Tessa has been brutally murdered with a doctor
friend, whom is believed to be her lover. I am not giving away important plot
points here, as the film is completely centered around Quayle’s determination
to find out what happened to his wife, and then continue her mission.
Meiralles makes a wise decision by playing the scenes of the
actual story out of order, not only because it creates more of a mystery, but,
similar to a film like Memento and Irreversible, the impact of the film is
not in the end of the story, but in the little moments in between, at the beginning
and spread throughout. Meiralles also told the story of City of God
and this seems like a good choice of storytelling for him as a director. The
film also bears his frantic handheld camera style, which also creates a sense
of unease in the film, as Fiennes’ character wanders throughout the African
landscape, never quite sure if he is in the same danger that his wife got
herself into.
The film is loaded with good supporting players, including
Danny Huston as a bureaucrat friend of Fiennes, who may or may not play a
larger role in Tessa’s death than we think; Bill Nighy as the heavy; and Pete
Postlethwaite as a doctor, who may also hold a key to the mystery of Tessa’s
death. Weisz is good in her scenes, most of which are told in flashback, and
Fiennes gives his best performance here since 2002’s Spider.
Meiralles has translated well into English and is making
interesting career choices. Unfortunately, a lot of great foreign film
directors get sucked into the Hollywood vortex
and lose some of their daring and their own style when they shoot their first
film in English. Though I liked City of
God better, The Constant Gardener-
also very good, is, in many ways a much more daring film. This is an angry
movie, which combines the passion of Meiralles the director with the critical
pen of author Le Carre, whose novels, in recent years, have become more and
more distrustful of British and American foreign policy. It is rare that a Hollywood studio releases a film this political,
especially in the current climate. Then again, Focus Features is the studio
responsible for Traffic, Far From Heaven and The Motorcycle Diaries- all films that do not shy away from overt
political statements, and that all happen to be great movies, I might add. The Constant Gardener is an appropriate
film to end the summer, as it is officially the last film to be released in
August. It has been a summer full of thoughtful movies, despite what you might
hear from some critics, and this film certainly deserves to be ranked among the
best of them.