BROKEN FLOWERS (R) ****
Directed by Jim Jarmusch. 105 minutes.
Starring Bill Murray, Jeffrey Wright, Tilda Swinton, Jessica
Lange, Sharon Stone, Julie Delpy, Chloe Sevigny and Frances Conroy. Released by
Focus Features.
Bill Murray has one of the most expressive faces in film
today. He merely has to turn the corner of his mouth in one direction and we
know his opinion of the situation in which he is involved. He only has to look
ahead or roll his eyes slightly to the side and we know if he is gloomy or
admiring how funny life can be sometimes. Murray
started as a comedic actor, but he does not use his facial expressions for
punch lines, though they can often be very funny. Instead, he comments on the
scenes in his films through the way he looks at other characters or, quite
often, away from other characters.
In recent years, there has been somewhat of a Bill Murray
renaissance. Charlie’s Angels not
included, Murray
has starred in Rushmore, The Royal Tenenbaums and The Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou with
director Wes Anderson, as well as Hamlet,
Cradle Will Rock and the lovely Lost in Translation. He has become sort
of a Johnny Depp for baby boomers. With Broken
Flowers, he has further extended his terrific resume of great choices and
turns in a great, but subtle performance.
In the film, he plays Don Johnston, which makes him the
constant butt of jokes for reasons obvious to film and television films and not
so obvious for others. Johnston
is a sad, lonely man, but arguably by choice. At the beginning of the movie,
his latest girlfriend, played by Julie Delpy, storms out on him, leaving him to
sit on the couch, watching black and white movies on television and listening
to sad music. The other portion of his time seems to be spent hanging out with
his neighbor, Winston (Jeffrey Wright, in a potential Best Supporting Actor
nomination performance). Winston is an Ethiopian man with three jobs, five kids
and a hobby of detective work. The film is a comedy, but does not poke fun at
Winston’s character.
In fact, there are a number of offbeat people in Broken Flowers, but they are not the
butt of jokes, but just seen whimsically as weird and funny things happen all
around them. It is a difficult act to have a film with a character who is an
animal communicator and another with a painting of her house on her wall and
not poke fun at them. But maverick independent filmmaker Jim Jarmusch is the
master of wry, deadpan humor. This film is often laugh out loud funny, but
never cruel or condescending.
Johnston
receives a letter in the mail that says he has a son with a former lover, who
does not sign her name or leave a forwarding address. Winston, playing
detective, sets up a trip for Don to visit five of his former girlfriends, with
whom his past courtships may have resulted in a 20-year old son. Don was a
former Don Juan, so, naturally, he is hesitant. His travels lead him to a
graveyard and visits with ex-lovers played by Sharon Stone, who has a
mischievous daughter named Lolita; Frances Conroy, who has a strange
relationship with her real estate agent husband; Jessica Lange- the animal
communicator; and a very angry Tilda Swinton.
In many ways, Broken
Flowers resembles Alexander Payne’s About
Schmidt, in that the film is about a man who realizes he has wasted his
entire life during the course of a road trip. In Schmidt, Jack Nicholson’s character tried to make a go of a new
life on the road in a Winnebago, while Don Johnston goes out looking for his
former flames because he seems to have nothing else to do. During the course of
his travels, he appears to get a better sense of the absurdity of the world and
the difficulty of human relations, which is brilliantly executed by a twitch of
Murray’s mouth
as he observes two teeny boppers eyeing a good-looking young man on a bus. The
film culminates with sort of a third act revelation in which Don confronts his
real desires for connectedness with others and even gives a few words of wisdom
to another weary traveler. Jarmusch, one of the great American independent
filmmakers, delivers a hilarious, sad and whimsical experience with Broken Flowers and Bill Murray is the
perfect choice to play Don, announcing his every heartache, hint of bemusement
and exasperation through a simple facial twitch.