BABEL (R) ****
Directed by Alejandro Gonzalez Inarritu. 142 minutes.
Starring Brad Pitt, Cate Blanchett, Gael Garcia Bernal, Mohamed
Akhzam, Adriana Barraza, Elle Fanning, Nathan Gamble, Clifton Collins Jr.,
Michael Pena and Rinko Kikuchi. Released by
Weaving four interlocking stories in four nations on three continents and portraying today’s world as a modern day Tower of Babel, in which cultures continually clash with one another and people cannot connect because of the numerous language barriers, director Alejandro Gonzalez Innaritu’s enormously ambitious, wrenchingly intense and emotionally draining Babel is a triumph of filmmaking. The director, whose previous films are Amores Perros and 21 Grams, not only revives his stylistic trait of obsessing about where stories start and finish and showing how every single detail leads to a conclusion in his latest film, but also explores the disconnect caused by language, whether it is people who cannot connect because they speak the same language, people who literally cannot speak or people who can speak but fail to say what is necessary.
As in 21 Grams, a single incident leads to another and its ripple effect is seen in four different stories. In the first, we meet two young Moroccan boys and their father, who are learning to shoot a rifle to scare away jackals from their livestock. The family is sold the gun by a neighbor. The boys, one of whom is the more well-behaved and a bad shot and the other who spies on his sister undressing and has good aim with the rifle, set off on their mission and, in the course of a stupid decision, shoot the rifle at an oncoming bus, hitting and wounding a passenger. The boys attempt to hide the truth from their father, as well as the gun, but their actions soon catch up to them.
Also in
Meanwhile, two children – Elle Fanning and Nathan Gamble -
whose parents are on vacation are watched over by their nanny Amelia (Adriana
Barraza), who desperately wants to go to her only son’s wedding in Mexico. But
she cannot find anyone to watch the children and decides to take them along
with her. The three are joined by Amelia’s nephew
On the other side of the world, a young, deaf-mute Japanese girl named Chieko (an excellent Rinko Kikuchi) appears angry at the world. We know her mother recently died and that she lives with her well-intentioned but sullen father. Boys appear to like Chieko until they realize she is deaf and cannot speak. She is prone to flashing them in the mall and making passes at her dentist, not because she is promiscuous, but because she is desperately in need of attention from anyone. She pops some pills, drinks some whiskey and heads off to a nightclub with her friends and some young men. The scene is one of the best portraying disorientation that I have ever seen. Chieko tries to get into the mood of the nightclub, where young people sweat, make out and dance to loud techno music. The film’s sound jumps in and out between the music at the club and the nothingness that Chieko hears.
The four stories all connect, even if just slightly, but the
point of editing them together in fragments, as Inarritu does, is to show how a
random event can lead to cataclysmic circumstances in a corner of the world
thousands of miles away. In 21 Grams,
the director also spliced together three stories to show how one tragic event
can bring three characters together and lead to a near-tragic outcome. Inarritu
does the same thing in
Babel is a complex
film – it is not, by any means, difficult to understand, but the manner in which
Inarritu connects his stories and characters and the emotional punch of the
four stories, which is heightened through meticulous editing, makes for a film
that is, at times, devastatingly sad, incredibly suspenseful and often deeply
moving. Some characters march to their fate in the steps laid out for them,
while some others are given a second chance. And, other characters are left in
a questionable state of flux and we are unsure whether their lives are going to
change and, if so, for the better or worse. Inarritu sees the modern world as a
place becoming intricately complex, where, for the world to survive,
nationalities and nations must find a way to communicate. In his world, the
innocent pay harsh prices, punishments far outweigh crimes and people must rely
on the kindness of people with whom they cannot communicate.